It seems the name 'Dogma' has become a lightning rod for intense discussions, not just about music, but about integrity, artistic vision, and the very nature of collaboration. Recently, the spotlight has fallen on a significant rift within a band bearing this name, revealing a narrative far more complex than a simple lineup change.
From what I've gathered, three members – Grace Jane Pasturini (Lilith), Amber Maldonado (Lamia), and Patri Grief (Rusalka) – have publicly announced their departure from the South American heavy metal/hard rock band. Their statement paints a picture of disillusionment, citing unilateral decisions, broken trust, manipulation, abuse, and what they describe as lies to fans. They express a deep concern that the current management, which they feel is not comprised of artists or musicians, is transforming the band into a mere brand, treating individuals as disposable. This, they argue, betrays artists, partners, and fans alike, undermining the very foundation of connection and shared stories that Dogma was built upon.
Their message is a powerful plea for transparency and honesty, urging fans not to support what they perceive as falsehoods. They emphasize that the social networks now operating under the 'Official Dogma' name no longer represent the true band or their values. The departing members are standing with those who genuinely create connection, but acknowledge that the power ultimately lies with the fans to decide who carries the music forward.
The official band account, however, has responded with a different perspective. While respecting those who contributed, they assert that Dogma is, and always will be, larger than any single individual. Their statement highlights creativity, collaboration, and evolution as core tenets, with change being a natural part of growth. They express gratitude for every member's contribution, stating that the vision and music continue to progress with the dedication of the existing team and the support of the fans. Their commitment remains to authenticity, freedom of expression, and building connections through art, emphasizing that Dogma is about what the fans choose to be, rather than who the members are.
Digging deeper, Patri Grief (Rusalka) shared a more personal account. She describes falling in love with the project, the aesthetic, and the songwriting, feeling a profound connection to her character, Rusalka, which was based on a deeply personal experience. She details her dedication, offering ideas, collaborating creatively, and engaging with fans on a personal level, often providing support and listening to their struggles. However, her narrative takes a sharp turn when she recounts being denied entry into the US due to visa issues, leading to her phone being confiscated and a 48-hour detention. Upon her return, she claims the management immediately sought a replacement and asked her to train them, without any apology for the ordeal. She details a pattern of what she describes as exploitation, including inadequate pay, being pressured to work without proper compensation, and facing gaslighting when raising concerns. The alleged dismissal of another member for requesting a proper work visa, coupled with the detention experience, left her feeling she had no choice but to leave. She also speaks of being forced to eat only two meals a day, facing dismissive responses to her concerns, and being told that women complain too much. Despite the hardships, she reiterates her dream of being a touring musician and her love for the Dogma concept.
Amber Maldonado (Lamia) has also spoken out, thanking fans for their support and highlighting what she describes as the management's attempts to intimidate fan club leaders and private fans into siding with them. She calls for an end to this harassment, emphasizing that fan pages should be organic, not controlled entities.
This unfolding situation reveals a stark contrast in perspectives, raising important questions about artistic integrity, management practices, and the emotional toll such conflicts can take on individuals. It's a reminder that behind every band name, there are human stories, aspirations, and deeply felt experiences.
