There's a certain charm to a home that whispers stories of its past, and 202 Terrace Avenue in Toms River seems to have plenty to tell. Nestled in the well-regarded Hickory Manor section, this single-family residence, built back in 1956, offers a glimpse into a classic ranch-style living.
Stepping inside, you're greeted by what's described as an "inviting" atmosphere. The layout features three bedrooms, a good size for many families or those needing a bit of extra space. One of the immediate highlights is the updated kitchen, a practical touch that blends modern convenience with the home's inherent character. And then there's the basement – a full one, no less, and heated, with a partially finished section. That’s a real bonus, offering a canvas for whatever your imagination dreams up, be it a home office, a playroom, or just extra storage.
But perhaps the most intriguing detail for many will be the original hardwood floors hidden beneath the carpeting. It’s like a treasure hunt for potential homeowners, imagining the gleam they’ll have once restored. It speaks to the quality of construction from an earlier era, a feature that’s often sought after today.
Outside, the property sits on a generous 8,276.4 square foot lot, providing a good amount of space. The backyard is fully fenced, which is always a plus for privacy and for keeping pets or children secure. A concrete patio is already in place, ready for summer barbecues or quiet evenings under the stars.
This home, listed at $389,900, is currently pending sale, indicating a strong interest from buyers. It's a property that seems to balance its vintage roots with necessary updates, offering a solid foundation for its next chapter. The Zestimate places its market value around $396,200, with an estimated sales range between $376,000 and $416,000. It's also noted as likely to sell faster than 97% of nearby homes, a testament to its appeal.
Looking at its history, the property was listed for sale on September 8, 2025, after a previous listing was removed in January 2009. The price jump from its 2008 listing of $252,000 to its current listing price of $389,900 reflects significant market shifts and potential improvements over the years. The tax assessed value remains steady around $234,300, with annual taxes hovering just over $4,000.
For those considering the financial aspect, an estimated monthly payment, including principal, interest, property taxes, and home insurance, could be around $2,504, though this is an estimate and can vary based on down payment and interest rates.
Ultimately, 202 Terrace Avenue represents a slice of Toms River living, a ranch-style home with the potential for personalization, set in a desirable neighborhood. It’s the kind of place where you can envision making your own memories, building upon the history that already exists within its walls.
